Online First Nr66

Psychiatr. Pol. ONLINE FIRST Nr 66 1–13
Published ahead of print 14 April 2017
Wojciech Kosmowski
FREE POLISH FULLTEXT: Elementy logiki, retoryki i erystyki dla biegłych wydających ustną opinię na rozprawie
FREE ENGLISH FULLTEXT: Elements of logic, rhetoric and eristic for expert witnesses giving oral opinions at court hearings

The aim of this article is to provide expert witnesses, especially psychiatrists, other physicians, as well as psychologists, with basic information on logic, rhetoric and eristic, useful in their professional practice. The reason is that these skills, undoubtedly belonging to the classical education, are not standard elements of teaching professionals in the fields mentioned above. Having the expert knowledge, ability to diagnose, to conduct a therapy and to prognosticate does not indicate the ability to conduct effective arguments. This work is based on Cardijin’s method (See – Judge – Act). It sometimes happens that a well-prepared expert opinion (psychiatric and psychological) is discredited for non-substantive reasons due to some eristic and rhetorical tricks. Having such experiences, some expert witnesses resign from giving opinions. To help avoid such situations, this work presents the most important definitions of logic, rhetoric and eristic. Examples of propositional calculus, selected models of reasoning, rhetorical figures and eristic tricks can be used in presenting professional expertise. These examples are accompanied by propositions of responses to arguments used by persons willing to discredit expert witnesses’ opinions. Furthermore, this work offers a scheme of answering questions and doubts of the parties in court hearings.

ISSN 0033-2674 (PRINT)

ISSN 2391-5854 (ONLINE)

Psychiatria Polska
is an Open Access journal:
Creative Commons: CC-BY

Zadanie finansowane
w ramach umowy
nr 739/P-DUN/2018
ze środków MNiSW
na działalność
upowszechniającą naukę

KRW PTP dziękuje 
firmie PPL – Koral – J.Koral sp.j.
za wsparcie finansowe 
udzielone w 2020 roku

Inne strony PTP:
Other PTP websites:

Psychiatria Polska
Thomson Reuters Master List
Science Citation Index Expanded
Journal Citation Reports
(Impact Factor 1,596)

Medline/Index Medicus
MNiSW (100 pkt)
CiteScore 2,4
(SJR 0,414; SNIP 0,707)
EMBASE/Excerpta Medica
Index Copernicus
Erih Plus, Cochrane Library

We recommend:

Pharmacological Reports


KONTAKT Z REDAKCJĄ - wyłącznie e-mail: 

Biuro KRW PTP - prenumeraty, faktury - wyłącznie e-mail: